Why SOLID Principles Still Matter in the Age of AI

Why SOLID Principles Still Matter in the Age of AI

Artificial intelligence can produce working code in seconds, but working code is not always easy to maintain. The SOLID principles remain useful because they help developers divide responsibilities, control dependencies, and make changes safer. Those qualities matter even more when AI tools produce large amounts of code that people must understand and maintain.

SOLID names five design ideas

SOLID is an acronym for five object-oriented design principles: Single Responsibility, Open/Closed, Liskov Substitution, Interface Segregation, and Dependency Inversion. Microsoft describes these principles as techniques for decoupling the internal parts of modern applications. Robert C. Martin’s design work presents them as ways to manage dependencies and limit the damage caused by software that becomes harder to change over time. (Microsoft Learn; Object Mentor)

These principles are not strict laws. Martin describes them as heuristics, or useful rules of thumb that require judgment. A design can follow a principle and still be poor if it creates needless layers or abstractions. The goal is not to make every class small at any cost. The goal is to make change easier to understand and control. (Martin, 2009)

Five principles in plain language

Single Responsibility Principle: A class or module should have one main reason to change. An order-processing class, for example, should not also format invoices, send email, and write database records. Separating those jobs makes each part easier to test and replace.

Open/Closed Principle: Software should be open to useful extension but closed to repeated modification of stable code. A payment system might support a new payment provider through a new implementation rather than by adding more conditions to one large method.

Liskov Substitution Principle: A subtype should work wherever its base type is expected. If a subclass changes the promises made by the parent class, callers can fail even though the program still compiles. Microsoft summarizes the principle as the requirement that a derived class be safely substitutable for its base class. (Microsoft Learn)

Interface Segregation Principle: Classes should not be forced to depend on methods they do not use. Several small, focused interfaces are often easier to implement than one large interface that tries to describe every capability.

Dependency Inversion Principle: High-level business rules should depend on abstractions rather than concrete technical details. For example, an application service can depend on a storage interface instead of directly creating a specific database client. Microsoft identifies dependency injection as one way to implement this separation. (Microsoft Learn)

AI increases the cost of coupling

These principles matter in AI-assisted development because coding tools make it easier to create functions, classes, tests, and integrations. They can also make it easier to add code without fully understanding the surrounding architecture. A generated method may work in isolation while quietly depending on a concrete database, a global setting, or an unrelated service. Those hidden connections make later changes more expensive.

SOLID gives teams a shared vocabulary for finding such problems. A class that handles too many unrelated tasks may raise a Single Responsibility concern. A method filled with provider-specific conditions may indicate an Open/Closed problem. A business service that constructs its own external clients may violate Dependency Inversion. These labels do not prove that code is wrong, but they help reviewers explain why a change may create long-term risk.

That review remains necessary because AI-generated code still needs human judgment. GitHub says developers should review and test generated code. It also says code review remains important for maintainability, security, project standards, and business judgment. (GitHub)

Principles support better AI review

SOLID can improve the questions developers ask about AI-generated changes. Instead of asking only whether the code runs, a reviewer can ask whether the new class has one clear responsibility, whether an interface exposes unnecessary methods, and whether a new model can safely replace the abstraction it implements.

Those questions can also make automated review more useful. An AI reviewer can identify duplicated logic, large classes, direct dependencies, or suspicious inheritance patterns. However, it cannot decide every architectural trade-off. GitHub notes that AI can assist with routine review work, while developers still need to decide whether a design fits the organization’s goals, values, and product requirements. (GitHub)

Small abstractions also give AI tools clearer boundaries. A request for a new implementation of a narrow interface provides more useful context than a request to modify a large class that handles an entire business workflow. The result is not guaranteed to be correct, but the change is easier to inspect, test, and reject when its responsibility is clear.

Use SOLID with judgment

SOLID does not require every piece of code to use inheritance, interfaces, or dependency injection. A short script or simple value object may not need additional structure. Applying every principle mechanically can produce needless complexity, which is another form of maintenance cost.

The lasting value of SOLID is that it focuses attention on change. Developers can use the principles to ask where a requirement is likely to evolve, which details should remain replaceable, and whether a new dependency will spread through the system. When AI can rapidly produce more code than a team can carefully read, those questions are not outdated. They help keep development speed from becoming architectural debt.

References

GitHub. (2024, February 22). How AI code generation works. GitHub Blog. https://github.blog/ai-and-ml/generative-ai/how-ai-code-generation-works/

GitHub. (2025, July 14). Code review in the age of AI: Why developers will always own the merge button. GitHub Blog. https://github.blog/ai-and-ml/generative-ai/code-review-in-the-age-of-ai-why-developers-will-always-own-the-merge-button/

Martin, R. C. (2000). Design principles and design patterns. Object Mentor. https://objectmentor.com/resources/articles/Principles_and_Patterns.pdf

Martin, R. C. (2009, February 13). Getting a SOLID start. Object Mentor Blog. https://blog.objectmentor.com/articles/2009/02/12/getting-a-solid-start

Microsoft. (n.d.). Code contracts: Inheritance and the Liskov principle. Microsoft Learn. https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/archive/msdn-magazine/2011/july/msdn-magazine-cutting-edge-code-contracts-inheritance-and-the-liskov-principle

Microsoft. (n.d.). Designing the microservice application layer and Web API. Microsoft Learn. https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/architecture/microservices/microservice-ddd-cqrs-patterns/microservice-application-layer-web-api-design